A place for thought and expression…

The Monster in the Lake

Before the kite fighting tournament, Hassan tells Amir about his dream where he and Amir prove to a large crowd that there is no monster in the lake.  Later, however, Amir claims that there IS a monster in the lake…himself.  At the conclusion of the book, what do you think the author is trying to say about the “monster in the lake”?  Is it related only to the characters in the story?  Or does Hosseini have a broader theme in mind?

Posted by on May 22, 2014 at 11:40 am | Comments & Trackbacks (29) | Permalink

Baba’s Last Bear

How does Baba’s illness and death affect Amir, both immediately and long term?  Remember, I expect you to be thoughtful in your response and to show some depth in your analysis.

Posted by on May 13, 2014 at 11:01 am | Comments & Trackbacks (37) | Permalink

The Nature of Sin

In Chapter Three, Baba tells Amir that, in his mind, there is only one sin–theft–and all other bad deeds are variations of theft (killing someone is stealing a life, stealing someone’s father, husband, son, brother).  Do you think that there is any truth to his definition of the nature of sin?  Or is this too simplistic?  Explain your response.

Posted by on May 1, 2014 at 11:07 pm | Comments & Trackbacks (33) | Permalink

“Perfect” or Natural

We briefly discussed the World State’s practice of using chemicals to guarantee a disease- and pain-free life that is cut off at the age of 60.  The idea intrigues me, especially since I have lived a life filled with multiple medications, tests, painful procedures, and surgeries.  But, seeing as I am only 23 years away from 60…well, that’s scary to think about.

Explain if you would prefer the World State’s method of a “perfect” life over a natural one, one that allows for a potentially longer life but also includes the threat of disease, illness, and pain.  Provide your reasoning for your choice.

Posted by on March 12, 2014 at 7:08 pm | Comments & Trackbacks (38) | Permalink


Considering what we know of a utopian and dystopian society, in what ways does this society fit the definition of each?  In other words, how has the World State attempted to create a utopia and in what ways have they failed?

Posted by on March 3, 2014 at 7:57 am | Comments & Trackbacks (38) | Permalink

Before and After

Compare Manor Farm at the beginning of the story under Jones’s rule with Manor Farm in the last chapter.  What changes have taken place, and what has remained the same?  Which scenario, in your opinion, is the better for the animals and why?

Posted by on February 11, 2014 at 9:15 am | Comments & Trackbacks (37) | Permalink

What Might Have Been…

Imagine that Snowball had been given the opportunity to lead Animal Farm.  Do you think things would have ended differently for the animals?  Would his leadership style have proven to be more beneficial to the running of the farm as a whole?  Or would things have likely turned out the same?  Be thoughtful in your response and offer support for your reasoning.

Posted by on February 3, 2014 at 9:55 pm | Comments & Trackbacks (42) | Permalink

The End of the Book

Out of all the characters who die, which one affects you the most and why?  Please be thoughtful in your response.

Posted by on January 1, 2014 at 11:08 pm | Comments & Trackbacks (25) | Permalink

The Bread Givers

Liesel witnesses Hans give bread to a passing Jew and then being whipped for it.  She later helps Rudy leave bread out for the passing Jews.  What do you think of Rudy and Liesel’s decision to do this, knowing what could happen?  Is it brave or stupid or both?  Explain thoroughly.

Posted by on December 23, 2013 at 11:14 pm | Comments & Trackbacks (31) | Permalink

The Human Condition

We have seen from the beginning that Death is often confused by humans and their nature and wonders if humans are “worth it.”  In Part Three, for example, Death says of Rudy, “In years to come, he would be a giver of bread, not a stealer—proof again of the contradictory human being. So much good, so much evil. Just add water” (164). Do you agree with his belief that there is goodness and evil in every person?   Explain why you feel that way and provide an example from either your life or society.


Posted by on December 10, 2013 at 9:18 am | Comments & Trackbacks (32) | Permalink